Proprietary Analysis of Nationwide ICHRA Enrollment Data Challenges Industry Assumptions About Consumer-Directed Healthcare and Employee Plan Selection Capabilities
New York, N.Y. – March 16, 2026 – Zorro, a next-generation benefits administration platform using advanced technology and big data to transform how America’s workers plan, pay and save for healthcare, today released findings from its 2026 Open Enrollment Analysis, revealing that employees make sophisticated, diverse healthcare choices when equipped with smart decision support tools — directly contradicting long-standing industry concerns about consumer-directed healthcare complexity.
The analysis, representing ICHRA (Individual Coverage Health Reimbursement Arrangement) enrollment data from employees across all 50 states plus Washington, D.C., demonstrates that 84% of enrolled employees selected a health plan using Zorro’s AI-powered decision support without accessing live assistance during the 2026 open enrollment period — a 9-percentage-point increase from 75% in 2025. This significant milestone occurred despite employees navigating 50-100+ plan options compared to the 1-4 typically offered under traditional group plans, and amid a challenging market environment where premiums jumped nationwide.
Key Findings Challenge Conventional Wisdom About ICHRA
Zorro's proprietary data analysis reveals three major trends that may reshape how brokers and employers think about ICHRA implementation:
1. Employees Made Diverse, Informed Choices Across All Plan Dimensions
Rather than defaulting to familiar paths or the cheapest options, employees demonstrated nuanced decision-making:
- Metal tier distribution: 40% selected Gold-tier plans, 30% chose Bronze, 24% selected Silver, and 6% opted for Platinum — a relatively balanced distribution across tiers during a plan year marked by significant premium increases
- Network preferences: 53% chose HMO plans and 31% selected PPOs, challenging the industry assumption that employees overwhelmingly prefer PPO flexibility
- Carrier loyalty: 64% of returning employees maintained carrier loyalty year-over-year, with 37% keeping the exact same plan
2. AI-Powered Decision Support Enabled Confident Self-Enrollment at Scale
The 84% self-enrollment rate reflects the effectiveness of Zorro's proprietary AI technology, which helps employees navigate complex insurance decisions through:
- Personalized plan recommendations analyzing thousands of data points including age, location, household size, provider preferences, and prescription needs
- Straightforward explanations that translate insurance jargon into clear trade-offs
- Coverage checks that ensure recommended plans include the providers and prescriptions employees rely on
- Conversational AI chatbot providing instant, personalized answers in plain language
When they needed additional guidance, 16% of employees chose to access Zorro’s human support, which was recently awarded the 2026 Silver Stevie Award for Customer Service Department of the Year.
3. Employee Plan Priorities Reveal Sophisticated Cost-Risk-Access Trade-offs
As part of Zorro’s open enrollment process, employees are prompted to rank the top priorities they are looking for in a health plan. Their responses demonstrated holistic thinking:
- 49% ranked "minimizing all-in costs" as their top priority (not just premiums, but total potential spend)
- 36% selected "reducing the risk of large, unexpected expenses" as their second priority (compared to 16% ranking this option first), suggesting employees prioritize risk management, but only after they secure basic affordability
- 23% prioritized keeping their providers — significantly lower than industry assumptions about provider continuity as a dealbreaker
"The data is clear: when you pair genuine employee choice with sophisticated, AI-powered decision support, ICHRA works," said Maya Perl, Chief Customer Officer and Co-Founder of Zorro. "Our 2026 open enrollment results prove that employees have a good grasp of what matters most to them in their health plan, and can make confident choices with the right tools. Validated by our 84% self-enrollment rate, we are demonstrating how technology can eliminate the barriers that have historically held back ICHRA adoption."
About the 2026 Open Enrollment Analysis
The full analysis is available at www.myzorro.co/resources/zorro-open-enrollment-2026-analysis.
About Zorro
Zorro is an AI-powered insurtech platform leveraging ICHRA (Individual Coverage Health Reimbursement Arrangements) to deliver affordable, flexible and personalized healthcare plans for employers and their employees. Zorro's pioneering technology helps brokers to sell, employers to buy and employees to engage with their healthcare benefits. Its advanced platform delivers sophisticated price quoting, streamlined employer management and comprehensive employee decision support to simplify administration, deliver budget predictability and inform important healthcare decisions.
Media Contact
Abbey Yvon
VP, Marketing
